By Carl Chinn, LMHC (New York) and LPC (Texas) · Licensed therapist since 2012 · Reviewed November 2026
From the outside, it looks like you’ve got it handled. Your family brags about you. Your friends come to you for advice. At work, you’re the example. Nobody worries about you. The suffering is real, and almost no one around you can see it. Everyone suffers and deserves a chance to feel like they’re thriving, regardless of their circumstances, including the people everyone assumes are fine.
This is sometimes called high functioning perfectionism, and it comes in a few versions. This article is about one of them.
You’re in a situation where you’re one of the most accomplished people you know. It’s perhaps hard to say that anyone in your family, friends, or local community is able to compete with you. You either have superior intellect, work ethic, resources, or something; you have an advantage.
Lonely at the top
One thing that can happen is that it’s lonely at the top, and despite the advantage and the success, there are few peers to journey through life with. This doesn’t require you to be at the top of your industry. Perhaps you’re just the strongest person on your local team at whatever it is that you do, and there’s nowhere left to grow toward. There’s no one to compete with. Here are a few examples:
- You’re born into some resources where you objectively don’t have to work hard. You’re confident, you tease your friends, and you objectively have people around you, but you feel alone.
- You’re an athlete, no one in your division can compete with you, and you’re haunted by the idea of someone coming up and displacing you.
- You’re number one in sales in your firm, but the money can’t buy you more of anything that will make you happy.
- You’re the lead of your class, or you believe that you understand things on a deeper level that others wouldn’t understand.
The last one is perhaps the one that most people can identify with, but it works equally for everyone in this category. The last is the most identifiable because it doesn’t require the actual advantage, just the perception of one: that no one would or could understand us.
King of the hill
There’s a pattern here in ecological terms, and it’s the Hawk-Dove-Bourgeois game, from John Maynard Smith‘s work bringing game theory to animal contests. Generally, the rule says that an animal that believes claims can be made on territory behaves in a way that aligns with “fight if you own the resource, retreat if you’re the intruder,” and doesn’t give up the resource wherever possible. The resource in this example is a real or imagined advantage that you’ve earned, inherited, or come to by chance. It can be intellect, finances, shares, points, whatever. It doesn’t matter.
The issue comes about when we hold onto a local advantage, the tallest hill that’s near us. We’re king of the hill, and moving to conquer a bigger hill would require descending the one we’re on first, a vulnerability inducing move that we’re loath to make. In fact, conquering this hill, or maintaining it if it was given to us, usually requires programming a lot of loss aversion in the process.
The emotional mismatch is that the process of climbing the hill we’re on, or coming to realize the hill we were born on top of, was fun. We enjoyed growing, recognizing the height, and seeing the displacement of our advantage. But when you’re the biggest fish in the pond you swim in, there’s nothing left to grow. We’re already at the top. It wasn’t being at the top that was desirable, it was the getting to the top, the journey, that engaged us.
Advantage isn’t a value
In a previous blog we talked about the recipe for happiness, which showed that our values are what induce happiness, as an indicator to keep going in the right direction. Advantage isn’t a value, it’s an outcome. Growth is a value. If you value growth, then in the process of growing you’ll feel good, as an indicator to keep growing. When you stop growing, say at the top, real or imagined, the good feeling stops with it.
The unpleasant lesson: when you’ve gotten what you could get from the hill you’ve grown up on, try to practice intentional humility, set your sights on the next goal, and let someone else take your spot. It’s real vulnerability. The part that’s most identifiable for most people is that this requires coming down off of the intellectually superior mode of believing that no one can understand you: practicing the humility that you might not have it all right, being open to other people surprising you, and accepting that you can once again become a learner, perhaps a lifelong one. It’s practicing something called the beginner’s mindset. It’s the understanding that when you walk into a new subject, you know in advance that your first martial arts class is going to be rough, cranky, and uncoordinated, and accepting being at the bottom of that hill when you get to it, rather than assuming that it’s top or bust.
Perfectionists will often struggle to start something they can’t guarantee they’ll end up on top of. This often leads to analysis paralysis, which prevents people from becoming proficient in the first place. That isolation is the horrible feeling our title is talking about. It’s zugzwang: any move you make is losing, standing still isn’t satisfying, you’re already at the top, and moving any direction from the top loses ground. Temporarily. And that’s the key: reasonable goals require the cost, including things like humility, baked into them.
That’s the third way to rightsize a goal: price in the cost, humility included, before you pick the next hill.
Make some new friends first
The first step is what Adlerian therapists affectionately call Gemeinschaftsgefühl, Alfred Adler’s term, or in plain English, developing a social interest. Before you decide to leave the hill you’re on, make some new friends, contacts, mentors, or advisors who can tell you about other hills to climb. Consider their interests, their investment, how it might be cool to try something new, and so on. It’s often not possible to see where a relationship will take you before you develop it and have the conversations. It does require humility to be open to opening up and letting someone in, and therapy can help you do that.
What helps
Different therapies have different ways of helping you confront this inside yourself:
- Cognitive therapies like CBT and REBT: offer ways to check your expectations for what you want out of life versus what you believe you need, should, or have to have.
- Solution Focused Therapy: can show you how you might plan the steps of expanding your territory, and how measuring the steps between hills, and what they’ll cost, can make the journey more emotionally affordable.
- Schema Therapy: offers to highlight how different kinds of childhood patterns can create a pattern of scarcity in us that makes us loss averse and avoid risks.
- Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: can help us identify what fearful thoughts are popping up in the background that we secretly autopilot our lives around, and may show us how to redirect our experience toward our values more consciously instead.
- Internal Family Systems Therapy: may help us recognize that there might be a firefighter role showering us with distractions whenever we try to start a fire that might light the path toward another hill to climb.
- Dialectical Behavior Therapy: may try to show us how our emotion mind may be making short term decisions that compromise our balance, or that our reasonable mind is in overdrive trying to enact more protocols to maintain our advantage.
If the hill in question is a job, this often gets filed under work stress, and perfectionism is a focus area in its own right.
Many of the above therapies are offered by various providers on the Become The Way directory.
About the author
Carl Chinn, LMHC, LPC is a licensed therapist who has practiced since 2012. He writes about therapy, attention, and decision-making at Become The Way. Read Carl’s full bio.
This article is for general information and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional mental health care, and reading it does not establish a therapist-client relationship. If you are in crisis or having thoughts of harming yourself, please contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (US, 24/7 by call or text), your local crisis line if outside the US, or call 911 if in immediate danger.
Newsletter
Get new posts by email
One short email whenever a new article is published — educational content only, unsubscribe anytime.
