Become The Way MSO logo

By Carl Chinn, LMHC (New York) and LPC (Texas) · Licensed therapist since 2012 · Reviewed October 2026

Do your goals look like you telling yourself that you just “have to” do it? In other words, you just require more willpower to get the work done, and if you had it, everything would be better? Maybe that is a way to move forward, but before you walk away with that recipe, what actually is willpower, and is there a cleaner way to cook?

Last time, the move was turning the goal from a noun into a verb. This time it’s about what’s doing the pushing.

The pieces of you that talk to each other

There’s something magical about the human experience where we’re able to address ourselves. Different schools of therapy handle this in different ways. You’ve likely heard of the id, ego, and superego from Freud, but there are many models of this. IFS says we have firefighters, managers, exiles, and the orchestrating Self. ACT has us try to find the observing self, and the thousands of versions of ourselves that pour out as individual thoughts we can choose to identify with or not. DBT says that we’re ideally a wise mind that balances an emotion mind and a reasonable mind in harmony. And many, many more. The point: we have pieces of us that address other pieces of us.

When one piece believes that it has it right, and that all of the other pieces need to listen to it, it can get pushy and demand obedience. The same way that we’re hesitant to obey commands in a non-consenting context, we usually rebel, dig in, push back, or sabotage things. There’s nothing like someone else trying to control you to trigger every fight, flight, and freeze mechanism you have. It’s actually one of these mechanisms at work that drives “willpower.”

Is willpower anger?

Anger can’t be diagnosed using the DSM, but it has some pretty predictable symptoms that are easy to recognize and empathize with:

It’s a stretch to say that willpower is anger, but it’s hard to say that they don’t heavily overlap. Willpower, then, is a sort of callousness we have with ourselves, or with pieces of ourselves, to micromanage something by force for short term relief, despite collateral damage, burnout, or sacrifice, in a spontaneous, unplanned way. We don’t say, “I’m going to have willpower in 3 hours.” If we try to invoke it, it’s right now. Even if now is 3 hours from now, it’s spontaneous. Perfectionists often rely on willpower like this, holding exacting standards, threats of incompetence, judgment, and shame (the sticks) to enforce outcomes.

The carrot or the stick

When we’re trying to train an agentic system, be it a pet, child, person, or otherwise, there are two options: the carrot or the stick. The stick is willpower: do this or else. There’s no critical thinking required past the threat. One of the issues with using the stick on yourself is that you know the stick can be threatened, but it rarely, if ever, gets followed through on. It’s an empty threat, and the trick doesn’t work many times without being enforced.

The carrot, on the other hand, does require critical thinking. It asks a “how question,” something that therapists have been using for years and that Chris Voss repopularized in Never Split the Difference. If you ask a how question, the other party has to think out a plan in order to answer it appropriately. For contrast, a why question just requires a defensive “because” answer, even if you don’t believe what you’re saying or haven’t thought it out well. The how question the carrot approach asks is along the lines of: how much do you want this carrot? Are you willing to do this or that to get it? Is there a bigger carrot that would be more of an incentive, one you would do this or that for?

We know from reinforcement learning, potty training a pet for example, that if you use the stick and rub a puppy’s face in the mess it makes to “teach it a lesson,” we end up confusing the puppy. It may just learn that you don’t want to see the mess, and simply do it behind the couch instead. It doesn’t know what you want, what the carrot is, what its incentive is to behave in a different way. When you take a puppy out every 30 minutes for 2 days and give it a treat each time it goes on the grass, it learns very, very fast to respond to the incentive and hold in the discomfort for the reward signal. It’s the difference between relenting to willpower and achievement seeking.

Does this mean you give yourself a treat when you do a good job? Maybe at first! But to keep it going, the ideal is to consider how what you’re asking your team of selves to do aligns with the person you want to become, and how your values align with that vision. When we rise to our aspirations instead of sinking down to the threat of punishment if we don’t obey, we begin to feel better. Aligning the carrot is the role of therapy.

What does that sound like when it’s you and not a puppy? The stick sounds like: “I have to finish this report tonight or I’m a failure.” There’s no plan in that sentence, just a threat. The carrot asks the how questions instead. How much do I actually want this done tonight? What does finishing it tonight get me that finishing it tomorrow morning doesn’t? How big is the piece I’d be willing to do in the next hour? You can’t answer any of those without making a plan.

That’s the second way to rightsize a goal: change what’s pushing you toward it, from a stick to a carrot.

What helps

There are many different interventions therapy can use to help you align the carrot, so that you feel motivated to reach rather than pressured to enforce:

When the stick is the main tool you’ve got, the result often feels a lot like anxiety, and perfectionism is a focus area in its own right.

Many of the above therapies are offered by various providers on the Become The Way directory.


About the author
Carl Chinn, LMHC, LPC is a licensed therapist who has practiced since 2012. He writes about therapy, attention, and decision-making at Become The Way. Read Carl’s full bio.

This article is for general information and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional mental health care, and reading it does not establish a therapist-client relationship. If you are in crisis or having thoughts of harming yourself, please contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (US, 24/7 by call or text), your local crisis line if outside the US, or call 911 if in immediate danger.

Newsletter

Get new posts by email

One short email whenever a new article is published — educational content only, unsubscribe anytime.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *