By Carl Chinn, LMHC (New York) and LPC (Texas) · Licensed therapist since 2012 · Reviewed November 2026
Outworking what you ask for
You’re working hard – really hard! You’ve got a family or partner to support, a complex job, demanding parents, whatever it is, you’re working your hardest not to let them down. You’ve even given up the things that you actually want in order to get the job done, believing it to be a noble sacrifice, and perhaps sometimes it is.
But something starts to creep in over time. You notice that you’re giving everything up, and you are holding things up, but nothing seems to meaningfully come back your way. Slowly, over time, you give more and more of your emotional savings account until you hit the bottom. It’s maybe at this point that you know you feel resentful, even though that’s the feeling you’ve been subtly nursing for quite a while now.
Why don’t people just pay us back, or see us, or try to help us? The topic of this essay is: did you ask them to? Not in a rub-your-face-in-it way, but rather logistically. Did you ask for what you wanted?
The problem solver role
Those of us who wear a problem solver role tend to do things that support that role continuing. We look for problems to solve, people in need, people with demands, or complex situations that require the horsepower we can offer. In a way, we find ourselves gravitating toward those situations, feeling at peace there, at first.
The catch: if your role is to solve problems, and you yourself ask for help, for someone to solve your problems, for someone to give you comfort, you’ve undermined your role. The version of us that “takes care of things” must admit defeat or surrender to ask for help, because that’s against its nature. We don’t ask fish to climb mountains or elephants to swim in the ocean. Similarly, a problem solver doesn’t ask for help or recognition.
Until you can’t do it anymore. This is admittedly, usually, a temporary state that we stay in. We eventually burn out, become resentful, lose purpose, or find unhealthy distractions that “fix” our own problems only to make them worse.
Doubling down
But there are ways to avoid that! The road to those endpoints starts with a simple decision that many people make. I’m working hard and I haven’t gotten anything back yet. I still feel empty. Even the compliments I get feel empty. What do I do?
Do I ask for help? Nope, too vulnerable, and it asks me to betray my role. Do nothing? Nope, I’m a problem solver, not a bystander. Double down? Yes, that’s what a problem solver would do: perhaps the reason I don’t feel good yet is that I haven’t worked hard enough yet. I need to keep working harder, and then, maybe my parents will approve of me, my partner will stop complaining, my job will recognize me, something will happen.
But it rarely does. Doubling down is the most intuitive and emotionally misguided solution. Though many people have gotten very wealthy doubling down, when they get to emotional zero, the money can’t buy anything they want. It happens a lot.
We try to outwork what we would otherwise be asking for if we weren’t afraid to ask.
Add asking to the toolbox
And there lies a potential solution. We’re familiar with fixing, not with asking. Adopting the role of an asker is too much of a role switch. However, could we add asking to our toolbox of tips and tricks to fix things, including maintaining ourselves? It doesn’t require creating an involved 100 step plan to change someone’s mind, nor a guarantee that we would be satisfied if we took the risk to ask.
People also tend to underestimate how often a direct request gets a yes, a gap Francis Flynn and Vanessa Bohns measured in a 2008 series of studies.
What can you ask for that’s innocuous enough to be reasonable to start with?
- Ask your partner to ask you more questions. To be curious about you.
- Ask for something to be delegated at work. You know there are people or programs who can lighten the load if you thought to ask.
- Ask your parents to list what they’re proud of, so you can leverage that to take on current adversity.
- Ask yourself: what would be outside evidence of you genuinely connecting with someone else?
The key and fundamental lesson to learn is that doubling down increases the sense of isolation, and we’re maximally isolated when we’ve surrendered everything to try to please others. The ask is not an admission of defeat. It’s a bid for connection, John Gottman’s term for any attempt to reach another person for attention, affection, or help. If you try to outwork connecting with people, it individually costs more than it returns.
What helps
Therapies address this in different ways:
- Cognitive therapies like CBT and REBT: offer ways to examine the rules underneath the role, like “I should be able to handle this myself” or “needing help means I’ve failed,” and check them against the evidence.
- Solution Focused Therapy: can help you find the times asking already went fine, and build the next small, reasonable ask from there.
- Schema Therapy: may highlight how childhood patterns of self-sacrifice or unrelenting standards can make taking care of everyone else feel like the only safe role.
- Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: can help you notice the fear that shows up right before an ask, and make room for it while still moving toward the connection you value.
- Internal Family Systems Therapy: may help you get to know the problem solver as a part of you, one that’s been working very hard to protect you, rather than the whole of who you are.
- Dialectical Behavior Therapy: offers interpersonal effectiveness skills, including a structured way to make a request clearly while keeping both the relationship and your self-respect intact.
This pattern is one of the quieter faces of perfectionism: if you can’t be flawless at carrying everything, asking can feel like failing. Perfectionism is a focus area in its own right, and when the load is mostly a job, it often gets filed under work stress.
Many of the above therapies are offered by various providers on the Become The Way directory.
About the author
Carl Chinn, LMHC, LPC is a licensed therapist who has practiced since 2012. He writes about therapy, attention, and decision-making at Become The Way. Read Carl’s full bio.
This article is for general information and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional mental health care, and reading it does not establish a therapist-client relationship. If you are in crisis or having thoughts of harming yourself, please contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (US, 24/7 by call or text), your local crisis line if outside the US, or call 911 if in immediate danger.
Newsletter
Get new posts by email
One short email whenever a new article is published — educational content only, unsubscribe anytime.
